It's becoming increasingly common for home sales to be handled through an estate agency. With that comes one of the most frequently asked questions: who pays the estate agent's commission? Here's a look at who is responsible for paying it and what the law says on the matter.
Follow idealista/news in Spanish on the WhatsApp channel
Is it legal for a real estate agency to charge the buyer?
Yes, it is legal, provided the buyer has hired the agency's services and has accepted the fees clearly and in writing.
In Spain, there is no law that specifically regulates estate agency fees in property sales, nor does it establish percentages or determine who must pay them. Based on Articles 1254 and 1255 of the Civil Code, agencies are generally free to decide how much to charge and who should bear the cost.
However, that does not mean anything goes. Buyers are consumers and can rely on the General Law for the Defence of Consumers and Users, which requires fees to be disclosed in advance and presented clearly and understandably. Otherwise, a court may declare the clause unfair and therefore null and void.
Who pays the real estate agency in a sale?
In a property transaction, the party that hires the estate agency is normally responsible for paying it. In most cases, this is the seller, who signs the agency agreement and assumes the commission.
According to Article 1257 of the Civil Code, contracts are binding only on the parties that sign them. The agency agreement is entered into by the property owner and the estate agency, and the buyer, who usually becomes involved after seeing a listing, cannot automatically assume those obligations without having expressly accepted them, as confirmed by Supreme Court ruling 663/1984.
Does the buyer have to pay a commission to the estate agency?
No. As a general rule, the buyer does not have to pay an estate agency commission. Viewing a property, making an offer or signing a viewing form does not create that obligation.
The viewing form merely proves that the agency showed the property to the prospective buyer on a specific date. When it includes a clause requiring the buyer to pay a commission if the purchase goes ahead, the courts have often considered such provisions unfair and therefore unenforceable.
How much does an estate agency charge the buyer?
There are three situations in which a buyer may legally be required to pay:
- The buyer hires the agency to find a property. In this case, the agency works on the buyer's behalf, negotiates in their interests and is paid by the buyer.
- The buyer signs a mediation agreement with clearly defined fees. The fees must be negotiated and agreed before the purchase in exchange for a genuine service. In such cases, the courts may require the buyer to comply with the agreement, as happened in a case heard by the Provincial Court of Córdoba.
- The agency operates under a dual-agency model. In these cases, both buyer and seller are charged, but only if the buyer has given informed consent and understands that the agency is also being paid by the seller. This practice is legal provided it is fully transparent.
Is it illegal for an estate agency to charge the buyer commission?
No. It is not illegal for an estate agency to charge a buyer a commission in a property sale, provided there is a prior contractual agreement.
The Consumers and Users Organisation (OCU)'s latest report on estate agencies in 2026 continues to identify cases in which agencies charge buyers while also receiving payment from sellers.
One example involves a couple who offered €280,000 for a property advertised at €290,000:
- The agency said it would consult the seller and later returned with a "counter-offer" of €283,000, which the buyers accepted.
- When the transaction was completed, they discovered that €5,000 of that amount corresponded to agency fees and that the seller would actually receive €278,000, the amount stated in the deed.
- After speaking with the seller, they learned that he had been told from the outset that the agreed price was €278,000 and that he had already paid his own commission.
- Was it legal? Yes, because the buyers had signed an agreement accepting those fees, giving the agency a contractual basis for charging them.
However, concealing the fact that both parties are being charged and presenting the process as a genuine negotiation may conflict with the transparency obligations established by consumer protection law. These are precisely the kinds of situations that may give rise to a legal claim.


