A ruling by the High Court of Justice of Catalonia (TSJC) has clarified a common point of confusion among property owners – declaring only the days a property is occupied is not enough, nor can all expenses incurred during the year be deducted automatically.
Follow idealista/news on the WhatsApp channel (in Spanish)
Tax reassessment for a tourist rental and IBI on another property
The case originates from an inspection by the Girona office of Spain’s tax authority, the AEAT, into the income tax return of an owner who held several assets – a tourist rental, another property leased as a main residence and a rented pig farm.
In their tax return, the taxpayer declared the income generated by the holiday rental but deducted all related expenses for the full year – ranging from community charges to interest payments. The tax authorities considered that this approach understated the actual tax due and adjusted the assessment on two grounds. First, they added imputed income for the periods in which the tourist property was not rented. Second, they restricted deductible expenses to the time during which the property actually generated rental income.
Furthermore, the Tax Agency examined the Property Tax (IBI) applied to the rented home used as a primary residence. The taxpayer sought to deduct this cost despite the lease agreement clearly stating that the tenant was responsible for paying it.
The review resulted in a provisional tax assessment and a penalty. The owner first appealed to the Regional Economic‑Administrative Court of Catalonia, which partially ruled in their favour by overturning the penalty, while upholding the tax adjustment itself. They then took the case to the High Court of Justice of Catalonia.
Imputed income in tourist rentals: why tax is due without earnings
This is where one of the ruling’s key points comes into focus. The High Court stresses that Spain’s Personal Income Tax Law not only taxes income that is actually earned, but also the potential to earn it.
As a result, a property that is neither the taxpayer’s main residence nor used for business purposes remains taxable even if it does not generate rental income. In such cases, the rules require owners to declare imputed income calculated in proportion to the number of days the property is vacant – provided it remains available for use.
For this reason, declaring only the days the property is occupied is insufficient. Owners must account for the entire year, clearly distinguishing between periods in which the property generates rental income and those in which imputed income applies.
Deductible expenses for tourist rentals: how to apply them proportionally
The second major point addressed by the ruling concerns expenses. Can costs be deducted even if the property is not rented for the full year? The court’s answer is clear: expenses are only deductible to the extent that they are directly linked to generating income – and must be allocated in proportion to the period during which the property is actually rented, requiring a pro‑rata calculation.
Where a property is let for only part of the year, expenses must be adjusted to match that same period. This applies to common items such as mortgage interest, local taxes, community fees, insurance, repairs and maintenance, as well as depreciation, management costs and agency fees. Expenses incurred during periods without rental activity cannot be deducted against rental income.
Property tax (IBI) and rent: when the contract does not match reality
As noted, the third point of dispute was unrelated to the tourist rental but to the property leased as a main residence. The owner argued that the rental contract incorrectly stated that the tenant was responsible for paying the property tax (IBI) – claiming that they had, in fact, paid it themself.
The High Court of Justice of Catalonia rejected this argument, finding that the owner had failed to provide any evidence to support their claim. As a result, the expense could not be accepted as deductible, highlighting the decisive importance of documentation and consistency between contractual terms and actual payments.
The High Court of Justice upholds the Tax Authority criteria and stresses proof
The High Court of Justice of Catalonia has upheld the Tax Authority’s position, reinforcing that the burden of proof lies with the property owner. The ruling applies established Supreme Court case law – specifically Judgment 270/2021 of 25 February – which states that any urban property that is not a main residence is capable of generating taxable income.
On this basis, the court confirms the tax authority’s approach: rental income, in this case from tourist lettings, cannot be separated from the mere availability of the property. Both occupied and vacant days have tax implications – although in different ways. Days with tenants are treated as income from property capital, allowing proportional expense deductions – while vacant days are subject to imputed income under Article 85 of the Personal Income Tax Law.
This strict interpretation also applies to expense verification. As the taxpayer failed to provide conclusive evidence that they had paid the property tax themself, the court ruled that their claim lacked sufficient proof and therefore upheld the tax assessment in full.
Tax tips for landlords and mistakes to avoid
This ruling highlights the importance of keeping detailed and well‑documented records of both rental periods and related expenses. The High Court of Justice of Catalonia stresses that the burden of proof lies entirely with the taxpayer – and, as the IBI dispute shows, any lack of supporting documentation will invalidate a claim.
Overlooking the tax implications of a property that remains available to its owner is not a minor error, but one of the most common triggers for tax inspections. The cost of non‑compliance can be high, as incorrect treatment of expenses or imputed income may result in tax adjustments, late‑payment interest and even penalties. In this case, the owner not only had to accept the revised tax assessment but was also ordered to pay €1,000 in legal costs.


